- Experience Xtra Freshness* with Colgate® Fresh Confidence Peppermint Ice toothpaste! - Its Xtra* Fresh gel formula is powered with a breakthrough cooling technology for an intense cooling and a super fresh experience! *vs. previous formula - Comes in Peppermint Ice flavor in red gel with Cooling Crystals - Switch to Xtra Freshness*! Switch to Colgate Fresh Confidence! - Try out our other exciting flavors: Spicy Fresh, Cool Menthol Fresh, and Bamboo Charcoal